Posted on Tuesday 23rd of October 2007 at 05:44 in Blogging

The Alexa redirect trick is a complete myth: and here's the proof

On October 2nd I started an experiment in an aim to prove/disprove a specific Alexa myth, and sufficient time has now passed for me to release some information on what I was doing and how well it worked.

Alexa is a hideous site for most bloggers because it offers a "traffic ranking" of your site. Basically, it tracks each user who has their toolbar installed on their browser; monitoring which sites they visit and how they interact with them. With this data they create rankings and graphs to offer some enlightenment as to how your site fairs up against others.

Unfortunately it's hurrendously flawed as I wrote here back in January: lots of sites use your Alexa score as a metric for how popular your website is. However, it relies solely on users who have the toolbar installed (which is an Internet Explorer only thing I understand). Unfortunately Seopher.com has 65-70% of users on Firefox, so that's an immediate 70% of my traffic that they couldn't hope to track.

alexa 2

So how do you force them to see "the real you"?
There are a few reported tips explaining how to improve your Alexa rank by forcing them to see how much traffic you are getting. No one actually installs their toolbar, yet lots of places look to them to validate your claims of traffic figures. Well, there are two methods that surface time and time again and I've tried them both within the past year, so here are my thoughts.

Method #1 - Show the Alexa widget on your site
The logic behind this was that each pageload would ping the Alexa server for your information, thus indicating how many people are visiting your site. Unfortunately I had this on my site a very long time ago when I was receiving only 120 visitors a day and it made no impact on my stats. I kept it up for 4 weeks before taking it down - so that method does definately not work.

Method #2 - Get friendly with the Alexa-redirect
This is the one I've tried for the past 3 weeks. The logic is that Alexa *should* count the redirect as a page-load. So you put in the redirect (http://redirect.alexa.com/redirect?yoursite.com) then the user is directed to yoursite.com under the premise that Alexa should record the pageload.

So here is what I did
I created a 1px square iFrame on the site which loads an Alexa redirect into it on each page-load. This iFrame was positioned absolutely 1000px to the left of the screen so regular users wouldn't see it, yet it would be loaded whenever someone visits the page. The theory was that Alexa would then record every single pageload on my site and therefore thrust my Alexa rank through the roof.

The traffic I experienced vs. the Alexa graph
On October 3rd (the day after installing the item) I had over 13,000 visitors and since then it has been returning to my normal 1,700 a day. So traffic has not been low. Below is a graph explaining what happened.

alexa 1

It's fortunate that in late August I had another piece of content reach a similar level of interest so we can compare two near-identical phases, 1 without the Alexa redirect iFrame and one with. As you can see, the two are nigh-on identical.

Two similar periods of traffic, two VERY similar graphs
What more evidence do you need? If the redirect trick worked then the graph would have gone through the roof compared to the previous period of activity, it clearly didn't meaning that this is yet another Alexa trick that doesn't work.

So there you have it, adding in Alexa redirects does nothing to improve your Alexa rank (well, it certainly doesn't help when you're just above the 100,000 mark as I am; it may help those of you who are ranked 500,000+). It doesn't work so I don't recommend trying it because you're just forcing an extra pageload on your site that no one is seeing. So hopefully that myth can die here.

 

Enjoy this article? Why not subscribe to the full RSS feed?

blog comments powered by Disqus
Who is Seopher?

This is me. I'm a 27 year old web
developer, blogger and entrepreneur
from near London.

I've done work for people like
Samsung, Vauxhall, Cadburys,
Chevrolet, Center Parcs and TKMaxx.

I've been running this blog since 2006
and have reached more than
1.7 million readers

I'm passionate about the web, heavy metal, zombies and cats.

Seopher
Subscribe to the RSS Feed

Stay up to date with Seopher.com by subscribing to the RSS feed, either in your browser or subscribe via email using the form below

Updates by Email

By subscribing by email you’re also subscribing to the Seopher.com newsletter; a periodical email outlining new reviews, competitions and other subscriber-only content

  • ReviewMeReviewMe
  • buy 125x125 advert for $50 pcm
Want to give your product/website exposure?

Paying for a featured review is a great way to give your product, service or website exposure. For as little as $75 you can have a full review on the site forever.

Advertising Bundle! Review + Banner = $100

Buy a review and get a 125x125 advert half price. Your banner gets displayed on over 541 pages for a full month.