Review: Ubuntu 7.10 Gutsy Gibbon (beta)
The biggest step forwards as far as I'm concerned is the improvement to the configuration of the X server. This means that you're now able to make changes to your display configuration without faffing around gediting your Xorg.conf file. This is a massive bonus for those new users who don't actually want to do things on a command line. As a "normal" user would expect, setting the screen resolution is a matter of clicks. Adding a second monitor is (theoretically) an easy process although I've not tried it myself.
"Ubuntu Gutsy Gibbon is the next step in the long road towards mainstream acceptance"
Fast user switching? Sound familiar?
Ubuntu now has the ability to switch between users quickly (sound familar XP users?). This is handy because you don't need to close down the current session to change users - which is a useful feature for an XP replacement system. Nice attention Ubuntu devs, good work.
Aesthetically pleasing!
Gutsy is going to be the first Ubuntu release to ship with 3d effects installed by default and that's a nice touch. In my work as a web developer I always encounter the attitude of general users that "if it doesn't look good, it doesn't work well". Frustratingly enough you can have the most awesome webapp in the world but if it has no stylesheet, it may as well not work. I'm applying the same premise to Gutsy Gibbon - it's about time that the Ubuntu devs saw that however many "helpful" features you include, you'll never hit a mainstream market unless it is attractive enough to make it's patrons undress themselves in it's prescence.

Therefore it's a good step forwards to include Compiz-Fusion in the default package; a step that should pay off in the long run by bringing in the superficial crowd.
Printing
I'm not completely bowled over by the improvements made to the printing side of Ubuntu (as I don't actually ever print anything) but it should automatically detect and configure your print settings. However, an impressive introduction is the PDF printer (something I recommend most people to have anyway); meaning you can print your documents straight to PDF without installing third party applications. Printer support is a good place to spend development time though, as they are a common peripheral and lack of support is a common cause of frustration. Remember kids, if you want people to use it - it needs to be soul crushingly easy.
"There's no point me looking through Synaptic or connecting to my home network because I just know it'll work"
Tracker!
Tracker is Google desktop search for all intents and purposes. It's able to index meta data contained within your files, folders, everything. From the contents of your documents to the meta-data attached to your Audio files: tracker searches them all. If you've never used something like this I whole heartedly recommend you try it - I use Google desktop search quite a bit at work (excellent for finding those pesky files that you downloaded without any thought as to where they went).

As you can see in the above screenshot, I made a text file called "rawr" and wrote some text with the word "cringle" in it. I opened tracker and performed the search and true enough, almost instantly the results were back with my newly created file. Smashing stuff.
Conclusions
To be fair, this is Ubuntu as we've seen so many times before. There's no point me looking through Synaptic or connecting to my home network because I just know it'll work. I've been toying with Ubuntu since Breezy Badger so I've seen how things are progressing. It just works and the new set of features they're adding look to be logical (but they fail to excite me).
Gutsy Gibbon is a very sensible development - it's not overstretching itself by reaching for the stars; it's adding quality features that normal users need to survive. I find it hard to get excited over improved printing functionality but I fully accept the important role it plays in user acceptance. This beta release of Gutsy is good but I've seen it all before - Ubuntu is great and this is the next logical progression. Good work guys, it's looking like another winner.
Enjoy this article? Why not subscribe to the full RSS feed?





Showing most recent 20 of 20 comments
And though the poor save some money from free Oses, they cannot afford the connection.
Devs should repackage their software the way Windows has done.
Wifi isn’t the problem it once was. It’s going on leaps and bounds - but it’s not fixed yet. What I would say is drivers are produced by companies that like to keep their secrets - what works on Windows is because a company has spent a huge amount of time, money and effort to make it so. What works on Linux, 9 out of 10, is because individuals have spent spare time and effort to get it to work.
Many wireless devices not recognised previously now work - I know this from experience. For love nor money I couldn’t get my laptop to connect to my home network, even though it could see it. Trust me - chance are someone, somewhere, is working on it.
For SIP videoconferencing/normal phone I switched to Linphone - which installs smoothly on Ubuntu with just a couple of clicks :-) (Version 1.7.1 is OK)
It has all the features Ekiga has and some more (such as better video codecs then h261)
Conrad
Btw, I use Ubuntu 7.04 on my Dell Inspiron laptop... run Windows based games on WINE, have been able to play all audio and video files (including H.264) Overall system stability has been excellent and to-date all updates have worked without issue (sure can’t say that about Windows at my office)
Complaints? Sure. Firefox seems to have a stability issue with Rhapsody’s music player on my laptop, but that’s not enough to convince me to re-install the Windoze that came with this laptop (thanks for nothing Dell!) My Mobility X1400 still doesn’t support Compiz to the best of my knowledge... just a driver issue... it’ll be resolved.
Anyone who is against DRM should be avoiding Windows Vista at all costs... it’s just one giant DRM installation meant to control the user. As a Vista user you are nothing but a potential thief in the eye’s of Microsoft... you can’t be trusted at all and instead of spending time writing useful code, they release update after update to disable unlicensed systems... all the while catching some innocent bystanders in the process. Anyone who is against their operating system having a remote kill switch integrated into it... yes, they too should avoid Vista.
Where all of the different distros end up helping Microsoft, I think Vista has partially helped offset this by being so blatantly horrible.
Ok, I’m done.
As it was and is in the last two releases
#1: doesn’t sound like a GNOME problem.
#3: sounds like a problem with the printer driver.
#4: when is the last time you used Ubuntu? sounds to me like you used an old version that didn’t have the ability to automatically find missing codecs and install them. (now a GNOME feature as well). plus for DVD you could install a package that allows you to play the encripted ones.
#5: that would be a problem with OpenOffice.org.
#6: apparently this isn’t a problem.
apparently, out of the 4 real problems you listed, 1 is a GNOME problem, 1 is an OpenOffice.org problem, 1 is a Canon problem, 1 I don’t know.
so the only problem you found with GNOME will be fixed in 6 months. no problems with Ubuntu. the other two are a problem with a third party app and lack of support for a comercial company. complain to the relevant people/organizations. about HD audio, it sounds to me like it’s probably a manufacturer that doesn’t support Linux, so why don’t you complain to them? maybe, if you complain, the situation would get better. maybe the drivers have been fixed/updated/created so your sound card and printer would now work properly.
LOL :-D Gnome 2.21 :-)
"that 1 big improvement comes up once a year - to fix all the above, would require another 5 years (or 2-3 in the best scenario)..."
ROTFL
Jam, you don’t even know what you are writing about - don’t do that...
Another important feature, is embedded read & write onto NTFS-3G (Window’s NTFS) Partitions.
Other than that, I can’t seem to see any other "usefull" improvement...
I have quit Linux, since I could:
1. Not set up HD Audio on my newly bought Mobo
2. Not VoIP chat through Ekiga
3. Not Print in Color with my Canon Printer
4. Not being able to play/view certain types of audio/video files on my Ubuntu PC.
5. Not being able to use OOO Calc’s Data/Filters (not as good when compared to MS Excel’s Data/Filter capabilities)
6. Not Setup all my Ubuntu PCs to auto-update from a single Ubuntu Machine (I used to have to download updates multiple times for each of the networked pc’s)...
I have read that Gnome v2.22 has plans to fix the Ekiga VoIP client.
Based on the above statement, since Gnome v2.21 is coming up in 6 months from now (i.e. March 2008), Gnome v2.22 should be coming up around this time next Year...
Based on the following assumption - that 1 big improvement comes up once a year - to fix all the above, would require another 5 years (or 2-3 in the best scenario)...
Thanks,
jam
I also use Debian---
But don’t say Fedora is bad, it only shows your ignorance...
Regardless, this wasn’t an Ubuntu revelation.