Array ( ) Review of Ubuntu 7.10 Gutsy Gibbon final release - Seopher.com


Want to stay up to date? Then why not subscribe to the RSS feed?

Or subscribe by email
Reviews are now only $20 Want a product reviewed? Now they cost only $20! Not bad for a site with 1,000 visitors a day
book yours now before they're gone
Posted on Tuesday 30th of October 2007 at 10:13 in Linux

Review of Ubuntu 7.10 Gutsy Gibbon final release

Open source software amazes me. There was a time when free applications were either completely twattish or pirated; yet as the months roll by more and more amazing things are happening - making a world without paid software increasingly viable. Here we go again, another new Ubuntu release to prove my point.

True, if you've used Feisty Fawn (7.04) then an awful lot of Gutsy Gibbon (7.10) will be familiar to you. I'm not saying that nothing has changed because they have introduced an awful lot of VERY important things, but at face value things are largely familiar.

"Show me one Vista user who isn't in awe of Gutsy Gibbon and I'll show you a liar"


Changes where they count the most
Regular people will count a pretty face as being a good product; so dress your software up nicely and people will love you for it. Us "techie" users won't and will always critise massive usability problems. This time around they've clearly aimed to appease both parties. They've satisfied my biggest frustration with Ubuntu and for that I'm awarding them major bonus points. They've also brought in some seriously weighty eye-candy - but we'll get to that later.

Graphical configuration - finally
A graphical configuration utilty is the single most welcome addition in Gutsy. Anyone who has used Ubuntu before with a slightly "advanced" technical setup will have spent many a minute faffing around in gedit, modifying the Xorg.conf file in an effort to get dual screens working properly.

gutsy gibbon graphical configuration

However, Gutsy has introduced a sexy graphical configuration area that removes this usability hurdle that has plagued Ubuntu since birth. It's one of the major factors that was stopping me ever recommending Ubuntu to "normal" people. Normal people don't want to command-line around the place trying to define manual resolutions for their high-street bought TFT. Ubuntu has corrected this to the delight of every single user (at a guess, I've not asked them all).

Equally importantly, the X-server configs have been made rather durable, so should the worst happen and it crashes (and burns in glory), should it be unable to restore previous settings it will default to a the stable VESA drivers/settings to ensure you get a GUI (albeit an ugly, low res one). This means that you should never be confronted by the command line telling you that Xorg failed to start. Which is nice.

Something boring but crucial - the new Kernel
This may seem monumentally boring but there's a very good point to my mentioning this; Ubuntu has stepped forward to Kernel 2.6.22 which uses a new "tickless" idle loop which results in improved power usage. Again, this sounds dull but laptop battery life could be extended by as much as 25% because of this - so while it's not the most exciting of breakthroughts, the practical application is excellent.

With this new Kernel comes improvements to compatability to things like Wi-Fi and other devices - and I know these are two normal stumbling blocks for a lot of people.

More boring stuff - printing
It's nothing dreams are made of but crucial none-the-less. Ubuntu 7.10 comes with a radically updated printing service which is an important factor for a lot of users. However, forgive me for not discussing this much as I don't actually own a printer (any printing I need to do gets done at work) so this isn't something that interests me personally.

Google Desktop Search
This is a very useful little feature that I've recently become a big fan of - after developing a mild dependence on the Google Desktop search that comes bundled with Google Desktop on Windows. It allows you to search through all the files, folders, documents (etc) on your computer as if you were searching the Internet. This funky little application named "Tracker" is able to read the meta-tags associated to media files too.

tracker search tool

This is useful because it's all too easy to lose files on your hard drive (even more so if you don't abide to a strict regime of file formatting). Tracker is installed and enabled by default and is a worthwhile thing to arm yourself with - you'd be amazed what it does for your productivity when you get all those sporadic minutes back that were previously lost searching for documents.

Finally, the aesthetic glory of Compiz Fusion
Ubuntu 7.10 comes with Compiz Fusion enabled by default (on all supporting platforms) which is a feature that an awful lot of users will enjoy. Any number of beautiful things can be achieved with this powerful window manager addition. It's pointless trying to explain the merits when I can show you in video:



The above video shows how visually pleasing Compiz Fusion can make an Ubuntu install. If you can show me one Vista user who isn't in awe of Gutsy Gibbon and I'll show you a liar.

The downsides
On a personal note I prefer KDE to Gnome so that's not really a shortfall of Ubuntu. The only annoyance I have with it are the slightly dull wallpapers (as many other users have highlighted). Therefore I highly recommend this updated set of Animal wallpapers which are very clever and attractive in equal measures.

This latest release of Ubuntu has lots of good features, but ultimately I'm more impressed with the graphical configuration utility for X than I am any level of aesthetic wizardry. It shows that the project is moving in one solid direction - mainstream acceptance. That's an excellent thing for Ubuntu to do and if they keep pushing the boundaries like Gutsy does, then they will remain the poster child of usable Linux for the foreseeable future.

Enjoy this article? Why not subscribe to the full RSS feed?




Did you like this article?
If you liked this article then please show your support and give me a Digg. If you'd like to get in touch with me, email me at steven.york@seopher.com
Want to stay updated?
Sign up to RSS updates by email (or subscribe to the full RSS feed)

Enter your email address:

Comments

Showing most recent 16 of 16 comments [View all comments]

I’ve Used Ubuntu for about a year and half now and im even considering leaving windows behind buut as much as id love to do that, windows dose have some things that i use offten like games mostly but other than that ubuntu is the most used for day to day tasks of listening to music ect ect nice review though ive tryed some other distros like PCLinxOS,Mandriva,Slax,Suse,Linspire ect ect probly most of them and found that some of them arnt up to scratch like Mandriva for example getting updates and installing them, dvd drive errors amongst other things,and i find it to be very bland aswell , countless errors over and over but with ubuntu noo problems what so ever everything works fine may take a bit of searching to get what your looking for in the driver department and what not but other than that ive had no problems using it and im not usually a fan of the command line but ive found it to be quite an enjoyable experiance over the usual graphical window set up but i have to say that dose come in handy when you have to see what the file is and want some visual imput instead of text but yes im rambling on all i can say really is its exalent if it keeps improving the way it is in the near future i shall disown windows alltoghther
Mr Spandex

Hi, I installed Gutsy Gibbon a few weeks ago. At first, I was very impressed, especially at how quickly it installed. I still couldn’t use WiFi, though, but I’m used to that. Then things started to go sour. I first had trouble with the few Wine apps I used. I assumed it was Wine (it wasn’t; it was the graphics driver for my laptop). Then I had a great deal of trouble multimedia. Then, and this was the deal breaker, I could no longer use my DVD drive. I don’t mean just for copy-protected DVDs, I mean for any DVDs. I saw on the Ubuntu forums that I was far from the only one. I had to download an ISO for Ubuntu 7.04 which I will re-install.

The combination of all the flaws was enough to mean that my laptop was no longer a usable machine.

I was burnt enough that I will not be upgrading again before I’ve read all the reviews.
Mark

I am sorry. I don’t agree.

I use Mandrava and I have used OpenSuse as well and both of these distributions are better.

"Graphical configuration - finally"

This has been in Mandriva and OpenSuse for a while!!!!!!
pieter

Hi guys, I’m new to this. I have Ubuntu Gutsy Gibbon, and it crashes constantly for no apparent reason. It even does that after I open 3-4 windows. Is anybody else experiencing the same? Is there any way to fix that behaviour?
Paolo

improve battery by 25%?
what are you talking about.
phoronix shows it to be worse than ubuntu.
just cause in theory it’s better doesn’t mean it is.
also, with compiz and other eye candy, battery life goes down

I installed gutsy 5 times today. (X2-3800,2Gb-Ram,Asrock AM2NF6G-VSTA). I definetly feel it buggy. It seems there’s a problem with EOF in some crucial files when i try to install updates, this locks everything. Bad hardware support, this distro can’t detect my onboard geforce 6100, restricted Nvidia drivers work on my PC BUT when i and update and reboot again the distro starts in low graphics mode...!?. My monitor is not detected automatically. My TV card (Pinnacle PCTV rave which i have since 2003) is not detected, I don’t know why but with this two lines in rc.local it starts working:
modprobe -r dvb-bt8xx
modprobe dvb-bt8xx

Flash & Java support is easier to configure.


Rafa

Yes snds24, it’s possible. You must use the alternate CD to install Ubuntu on your PC. There is an option during the installation to choose where to install the GRUB bootloader
MadMax

Is there possibilty to install GRUB to root instead MBR?
snds24

Gusty is a great Linux Desktop. I personally favor my Gnome PCLinuxOS with the 2.6.22 Kernel and Compiz Fusion installed but I could certainly make do with Ubuntu Gusty. Here is a different look for Compiz Fusion in Gusty.

http://media.putfile.com/Ubuntu-710-With-Compiz-Fusion
BobbyC

Though your review is tongue-in-cheek, i agree with most of your points. I installed Gutsy on my laptop and desktop and both were flawless and needed no further tweaking.

As a person who does lots of printing, the new print installation feature was a blessing. I just plugged my Epson 1290 and R230, and both were instantly recognized and was ready for use in under 30 seconds. No intervention needed, just plugged them in.

I’ve used several Linux distro’s and with Ubuntu Gutsy, i must say my distro-hopping days are over.
burik

Hi!

This dist version makes one big different - I have heard serious Windows users begin to talk about Ubuntu for some reason.. U know alla of a sudden you have a person who never mentions a subject during smalltalk and then one day they do talk about it which makes you wonder how could that be..hmm!
And it not just one, it is several of them (work, buddies etc).
This combined with more people not so impressed by Vista equals better impact of Ubuntu. Me like it alot!
Per Tuneld

I’m a Vista and OpenSuse user and recently installed Ubuntu on a third partition. The splash screen doesn’t come up, so all you see during boot up is a blank screen, wondering the first few times if the thing crashed. Nothing I’ve tried so far has made the splash screen appear either at boot up or shutdown.

The touted graphical interface just didn’t recognize my second monitor, didn’t even realize it was there. After much fiddling I got it to see the second monitor but never got the right resolution for it. Finally had to edit xorg.conf manually. So much for that.

Compiz Fusion is nice but makes my system terribly unstable. And then every 2 out of 3 times the system locks at shutdown. And it also locks up during use from time to time.

Am I awed? Not a chance, and I dare you to call me a liar.
Roberto

Gusty Gibbon is the law!!!!
Mimer

Good constructive criticism of both the article and of Gutsy Gibbon dear nameless person

One question though, why use a bundled desktop search app over Google’s own product when Google have already proven themselves to you with their Windows version of the same product?

Oh, and I was always of the opinion that Google Desktop was primarily for searching and that the other functionality was just the add-on to it. :)
Adam

Reads fine to me, I’ve not experienced any major problems on 7.10 yet? What setup are you running nameless person?
James

You call that a review? What about the instability --laptops locking up instead of suspending. Random crashes while playing 3d games such as "alien arena", etc?


Add a comment





Prove you are real