Posted on Thursday 18th of January 2007 at 13:46 in Linux

KDE or Gnome? Some useful advice for new users

In a continued effort to help the GNU/Linux movement I've taken it upon myself to write some guidelines on a topic that is rather confusing for someone new the Linux. I aim to help answer the second question that most people ask.

The first question
The first question people ask when nudged in the direction of Linux (besides "what is it?") is "what distribution should I use?". This question cannot be answered by anyone other than themselves because that decision is based primarily on your individual needs and there is plenty of distro advice available on the internet.

kde or gnome KDE or Gnome?
This is the killer question that can be quite difficult to answer and there appears to be very little information available on the first couple of pages of search engine results for the new Linux user. Which is best for someone moving from Windows? What about someone moving from a Mac? I aim to help answer these questions.

What "people" say


It's a common belief that Gnome is the most natural environment for the newly converted, with a lot of time and developed focused on a more intuitive user experience. The success of distros such as Ubuntu are evidence of this but there's still an awful lot that relies on the user - what you prefer, what you use your machine for, what your requirements are, what your specifications are... The list goes on.

A quoted comparison
Alan Cox (a Red Hat exec) commented in The Register that "Everything else in the free software world gives you a package and the best (distro) is used. The fact KDE and Gnome exists suggest they serve different groups of users, KDE provides more configuration and control, and Gnome more ease of use while giving up that control." An ambiguous quote true enough but this almost summarises what you'll find when comparing the two environments - which is surprisingly un-useful for the end user - what you actually want is a summary of what you could expect from each given your requirements.

KDE


As a matter of personal preference, I find KDE the most intuitive for a native Windows user because the layout seems the most obvious. However, personal preference aside, here are the characteristics associated with KDE:

- Graphical tools to make life easier (such as the 'browse as root' option seen in Knoppix)
- Most Linux programs written for the X-display are designed for KDE (this was true in the past, maybe less so now)
- Plenty of eye candy available (distros such as PCLinuxOS come with full Vista-esq window transparencies)
- Typically very customisable

Overall KDE is noted as being more 'flashy' and customisable, some may call it bloated, others may call it 'fully formed'. It has been slated as being slow when compared to Gnome but it's probably more like what you would expect from an operating system having come from Windows.

KDE of Choice
I have two very clear KDE recommendations:
kubuntu pclinuxos

Gnome


Gnome has been made mainstream through distros such as Ubuntu, broadcasted as the most intuitive interface possible - in an attempt to make Linux more approachable for Windows convertees. Here are some of the characteristics associated with Gnome:

- Quoted to be faster on older hardware (450mhz for example) than KDE due to focusing more on function over form.
- Easy visual customisability (installing themes is 'easier' than in KDE)
- Gnome is less 'cluttered' and more simple than KDE
- Nautilus is quoted as being more stable than Konqueror


Gnome of choice
One word, Ubuntu.
ubuntu

A basic rule of thumb


If you're running an old machine and just require stability and an uncluttered approach then you're best looking into Gnome. However, if you love eye-candy and pretty window managers then KDE is your best bet.

Conclusion
To be fair, the barriers between the two are decreasing as time goes by, saying KDE is for eye-candy is almost a redundant statement seeing as the Beryl/Compiz stuff can be added to Gnome environments... Conversely saying Gnome is faster than KDE is also a slightly odd statement, as certain precompiled KDE releases are notably faster than their Gnome equivalents... Not that I'm saying the content in this article isn't of any use, but I feel that it should be down to personal preference.

KDE - the GUI child of OSX and XP?
I read somewhere that they felt KDE environments look a lot like the OSX GUI and I suppose there's an element of truth in that - but my experience of KDE (especially PCLinuxOS) is that it's far more "Windows-y" than Gnome - despite Gnome being popularised as "the environment to convert windows users".

As always, time well tell, I just hope this information was useful to someone trying to work out which is right for them, KDE or Gnome.

Please, I WILL have missed things out because I'm not an expert so if you see a glaring omission - place it in the comments.

 

Enjoy this article? Why not subscribe to the full RSS feed?

Add Your Comments








Comments

Showing most recent 20 of 48 comments [View all comments]

That’s something,That's what I was thinking.Brilliant idea.
That’s something,That's what I was thinking.Brilliant idea.
Fancy knowing that.I'm counting on you.
Many people are dreaming of wearing rolex watch as it is a great brand designer watch.Women like to wear all kinds of fashionable accessories sun as the Replica Yachtmaster watches which make them look more fashionable and graceful.man like to wear all kins ofFranck Muller watches to highlight them life style at a fraction of the cost.
Replica Rolex watches. Are you looking for cheap designer Rolex,http://www.watchwax.com provides the best Links of Swiss Rolex replica, replica watches,replica Rolex watches.
agreeable article
ugg boots
http://www.brawbuy.com/specials.html
http://www.brawbuy.com/timberland-classic-c-32.html
http://www.brawbuy.com/ugg-classic-tall-c-5.html
ghd hair straighter
http://www.ghdprincess.com/ghd-iv-mk4-dark-hair-straightener-flat-model103002-p-1152.html
http://www.ghdprincess.com/chi-hair-straighteners-c-2.html
http://www.ghdprincess.com/products_new.html
http://www.himk4.com/ghd-iv-mk4-pink-hair-straightener-flat-p-1755.html
http://www.himk4.com/chi-pink-dazzle-flat-iron-p-1766.html myjerseysky
http://www.myjerseysky.com/
http://www.myjerseysky.com/reebok-nfl-jerseys-pittsburgh-steelers-56-lamarr-woodley-black-p-1599.html
http://www.myjerseysky.com/reebok-san-francisco-49ers-frank-gore-premier-team-color-jersey-p-1681.html
Purple Ugg Boots 5819 classic Cardy Model:1010307
$260.00 $100.00
Save: 62% off
Inspired by the popular UGG Australia Classic Crochet, the Women's UGG Cardy is the footwear equivalent of your comfiest cardigan sweater. With soft, wool-blend knit uppers and lowers, this style features 3 oversized buttons that allow you to wear the uppers fully buttoned, partly buttoned, slightly slouched or completely cuffed down. Light, flexible, grooved outsoles deliver excellent traction, and suede heel guards enhance durability. Inside, soft sheepskin sock liners deliver cushiony comfort and breathability all year round. 15" tall. Imported.
Australia Sheepskin UGG Boots Sale,Wholesale and Dropshipping Available.
The Best Discount
you can click here to know more:
http://www.shoesiii.com; --UGG boots,timberland boots
http://www.mylacoste.com/ --NFL jerseys
http://www.ghdlinks.com --hair straightener flat
http://www.hibose.com/ --Bose In-Ear Headphones
Timberland Roll-Top Boots menwaterproof leather for comfort, durability and abrasion resistance; Direct-attach, seam-sealed, waterproof construction keep feet dry in any weather ; Padded collar for a comfortable fit around the ankle and help keep out debris ; When rolled down the leather lining is exposed ; Durable laces with Taslan? fibers and rustproof hardware for long-lasting wear ; Footbed and inside of shoe is completely lined with soft, breathable leather ; Non-marking, rubber lug outsole for traction and durability
Welcome to purchase online or contact us and we will be happy to

provide you with the best quality service of replica rolex .
replica watches paypal is loved by many young people.It’s one of hot

items of our company.If you haven’t worn fake rolex watches you are

missing out.They are fashiona and nice.
your change can change lives
http://www.myjerseysky.com/products_all.html
your change can change lives
http://www.himk4.com/
your change can change lives
http://www.myjerseysky.com/products_new.html
your change can change lives
http://www.ghdprincess.com/
your change can change lives
http://www.brawbuy.com/

With the growing popularity of smart phones, smart phones have become people’s first choice for purchase.
It's a good idea .Thank you.
Shopping for a Rolex watch online can tag heuer make the job Rolex Watches easier but you Replica Watches lso have to be patek philippe wary about the reputation of the dealer Chanel Watches and the brand of Breitling Watches watch you are audemars piguet getting. The more mont blanc watches considerable you are, the less danger you would come to armani watches when buying a Omega Watches gold watch online.

hey're a company who offer contextual, product oriented advertising for your site. The most common format is their eMiniMall (you can see a live example at the bottom of this page at the time of writing). They're common/popular because legend had it that they performed better than Google Adsense.
Your site contain a many useful information.
We are Rolex watch experts selling only the finest, top level condition, and preowned men's and ladies' Rolex watches, used Rolex watches, unused Rolex watches and new Rolex watches on the market. Our top priority is to provide every customer with the highest quality Rolex watch at the lowest price available. Browse our wide selection of Rolexes for sale.
ed hardy ed hardy
ed hardy clothing ed hardy clothing
ed hardy jeans ed hardy jeans
replica watchreplica BreguetRolex Milgauss replicaRolex Day Date watcheschopard replica
This is very useful for me,
thank you very much,
I think you will be successful!
Here is the best Tiffany shop online.Tiffany jewellery and Tiffany uk Tiffany jewelllery uk Tiffany jewellery sale Tiffany jewellery london silver jewellery Tiffany jewelry
tiffany rings
tiffany sets
tiffany bracelet
tiffany necklace
tiffany pendant
tiffany earrings

Subscribe to the RSS Feed

Stay up to date with Seopher.com by subscribing to the RSS feed, either in your browser or subscribe via email using the form below

Updates by Email

By subscribing by email you’re also subscribing to the Seopher.com newsletter; a periodical email outlining new reviews, competitions and other subscriber-only content

  • Wordpress Campaign Manager
  • 125x125 banner only $50 pcm
Want to give your product/website exposure?

Paying for a featured review is a great way to give your product, service or website exposure. For as little as $50 you can have a full review on the site forever.

Advertising Bundle! Review + Banner = $70

To kick start the new improved Seopher.com, buy a review and get a 125x125 advert half price. Your banner gets displayed on over 450 pages for a full month.